Myalgic Encephalomyelitis Diagnosis
In more recent years, most doctors finally realize that ME/CFS is an actual physiological illness with devastating implications for the individuals affected. Despite its high prevalence and disabling nature, medical education programs rarely cover ME/CFS and guidance for practicing clinicians has often been outdated and inappropriate, however things are finally changing. Fortunately, many patients and activists have begun to work together and demand acknowledgement of ME/CFS and have pushed significant health organizations to recognize it, and many research studies are finally being done illustrating neurologic, immunologic, autonomic, and energy metabolism impairments.
While there is no blood or other laboratory test to diagnose ME/CFS yet, there is hope, because ongoing research is identifying physiological abnormalities in the brains and bodies of people with ME/CFS. People who meet the suspected ME/CFS criteria should have a number of tests, including urine and blood tests and investigations to rule out other causes for the symptoms. However, it should be noted that ME/CFS should not be referred to as a diagnosis of exclusion, because Post-Exertional Malaise (PEM) is the cardinal symptom of and is unique to ME/CFS. No other condition results in immediate or delayed worsening of symptoms due to physical, cognitive, social, emotional, orthostatic or sensory exertion/stimulation. To call it a diagnosis of exclusion would be a misrepresentation.
Symptoms vary from person to person and can be more or less severe in the same person from one day to the next. The effects of various symptoms can also become more potent with physical or mental exertion and increased stress, causing more physical or mental exertion and causing the cycle to get progressively worse. Physical symptoms are more prominent before patients have had a chance to learn how to accommodate their lives to the illness and stay within their energy envelope. Spoon Theory is often referenced, for those living with chronic illnesses (ME included), to discuss one’s energy levels and how much each activity of daily living uses up. The amount of energy (“available spoons”) can fluctuate daily and often hourly, in people with ME/CFS. Here is a great example of how people with chronic illnesses (ME included) must manage their energy every hour of every day.
Fortunately, ME/CFS does not have to be difficult to diagnose, if doctors ask the right questions and use the criteria that have already been developed.
The most appropriate diagnostic criteria are the Institute of Medicine Criteria (2015), the International Consensus Criteria (2011) and the Canadian Consensus Criteria (2003). The field has previously been undermined by lax criteria that scaled misdiagnoses and contributed to ongoing stigma and discrimination. The Oxford, Fukuda and NICE 2007 criteria should not be used, and research studies using those criteria do not apply to ME. (DoctorsWith.ME)
In what follows, we reference the 2015 Institute of Medicine (now known as the National Acedemy of Medicine) evidence-based clinical diagnostic criteria, which focus on identifying the core hallmarks of the disease.
The core/distinctive symptoms of ME/CFS include:
Substantial reduction or impairment in ability to engage in pre-illness activity that persists for 6 months or more and is accompanied by fatigue. The fatigue is profound, not lifelong, not the result of ongoing exertion, and not alleviated by rest. (Note of interest: The New 2021 NICE document on ME/CFS published in Oct. 2021 has suggested shortening it to 3 months.)
Post-exertional malaise (PEM) in which physical or mental activities result in a delayed exacerbation of symptoms and reduction in functioning.
Unrefreshing sleep
Either cognitive impairment and/or orthostatic intolerance. These core features of illness must be moderate to severe and present at least 50% of the time; this is important in identifying ME/CFS from other common causes of chronic fatigue. (Important distinction: Chronic fatigue (a symptom of many other illnesses) is NOT the same as Chronic Fatigue Syndrome, the illness/disease).
This CDC ME/CFS Assessment Overview is another resource that you will find useful.
The DePaul Questionnaires (DSQ-2 and DSQ-PEM) are also very useful as they ask many relevant questions and will help you get a good history from the patient. The DSQ-2 focuses on Symptoms, and the DSQ-PEM focuses on Post-Exertional Malaise. There is also a DePaul questionnaire specifically for pediatrics (DSQ-PSQ)
Note: As many as 91% of patients are thought to be undiagnosed. This has to change, in order that people with ME/CFS can learn to manage their symptoms earlier, reduce the frequency and severity of PEM, and thus reduce long-term, permanent damage to their bodies, and improve their quality of life. Dr. Brayden Yellman, M.D., explains the potential for permanent damage at Minutes 28-33 of this video.
Family doctors might refer patients to see a specialist, like a neurologist, internal medicine, rheumatologist, or sleep specialist, to check for other conditions that can cause similar symptoms, but family doctors can play an important role in identifying and diagnosing ME/CFS promptly, when they know what to look for. It is essential for patients to keep a journal to document appointments, test results, and activities before or after the meeting, to document ANY changes to one's health. This can help them remember important details and conversations during their healthcare visits.
The healthcare provider will ask many questions to get a better idea about the illness. Questions might include:
What are you able to do now?
How does it compare to what you were able to do before?
How long have you felt this way?
Do you feel better after sleeping or resting?
What makes you feel worse? What helps you feel better?
What happens when you try to push to do activities that are now hard for you?
Are you able to think as clearly as you did before becoming ill?
What symptoms keep you from doing what you need or want to do?
The evaluation may involve tests for the following conditions:
Chronic infections, such as mononucleosis or Lyme disease.
Chronic conditions, such as diabetes, anemia, hepatitis, or HIV.
Nervous system disorders, such as fibromyalgia.
Sleep disorders, such as obstructive sleep apnea.
Autoimmune disorders, such as multiple sclerosis or lupus.
Heart or lung impairment.
Endocrine disorders, such as hypothyroidism.
Mood disorders, such as clinical depression.
Autonomic function tests (e.g. tilt-table testing).
Chest X-ray if there is a history of chronic cough.
MRI scan of brain if multiple sclerosis is considered possible.
Muscle biopsy if serum creatine kinase is raised.
Rheumatology and autoantibody screen.
Schirmer's test if dry eyes.
Serum estradiol and follicle-stimulating hormone if there is significant premenstrual exacerbation of symptoms.
Serum prolactin and neuroradiology investigations if there are symptoms that could be caused by a pituitary tumour.
Short synacthen (ACTH) test if plasma or urinary cortisol is low with symptoms (i.e. weight loss, nausea, pigmentation of non-sun exposed areas).
Patients with polycystic ovarian syndrome may experience fatigue as part of the metabolic syndrome.
Myalgic Encephalomyelitis Treatment
Unfortunately, there is currently no treatment or cure for ME/CFS, but patients may work with a doctor or other medical professionals to help them manage their symptoms and co-morbid conditions. Every ME/CFS patient is different, and different treatments will affect people differently, but the key is to make every effort to improve the patient’s quality of life to some degree.
“Science is making great strides but unfortunately, returning to what life was like before getting ill is not usually possible for people with ME/CFS, FM (fibromyalgia) and MCS (multiple chemical sensitivities). “ Dr. Ellie Stein, Person with ME, Calgary, Alberta
Co-morbid conditions are those conditions that have symptoms that may overlap or worsen those caused by the ME/CFS. Treatment of these co-morbid conditions will not cure the ME/CFS, but can improve the quality of life for the individual. These co-morbid conditions should be tested for and treated by physicians and can include:
Orthostatic Issues/Dysautonomia such as POTS (Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome), hypotension (low blood pressure), etc - Family doctors can use the NASA Lean Test for ME/CFS (Bateman Horne Center) - can be done in office by physicians or at home by patients who can then take the results to their physician(s). Tilt Table Testing can be used in more complex cases, but it’s currently not something readily available to Manitobans, but would be beneficial for Government officials to consider funding for future patient assessment. The Nasa Lean Test (and/or the Tilt Table Test) can provide objective evidence of orthostatic intolerance issues in some people with ME/CFS. Here is more information from Dr. Brayden Yellman about Orthostatic Intolerance in people with ME/CFS, and here’s the 2020 Canadian Cardiovascular Society Position Statement on Postural Orthostatic Tachycardia Syndrome (POTS) and Related Disorders of Chronic Orthostatic Intolerance (This article is NOT ME specific, but provided here as a resource due to it being a comorbidity of ME.)
Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS). Here is the most updated Global Consensus 2 Criteria for diagnosis of MCAS, which included Dr. Lawrence B. Afrin, M.D.
“This document is the most recent "consensus" document on MCAS. It was written in response to criticism of the earlier consensus document of 2011 which many in the field believed resulted in too restrictive diagnostic profile leaving many with MCAS improperly or undiagnosed. This document is criticized for possibly capturing too many individuals under the MCAS diagnostic umbrella but the argument is made that clinical treatment can then determine whether the diagnosis fits based on patient response to treatment.
Take a look at the broad range of symptoms MCAS can generate. Are your complex, chronic patients familiar with this? Have they been examined for this? Increasingly it is seen that inclusion of MCAS management in those with ME/CFS makes a meaningful difference in symptoms.” (Credit to the “Physical Therapist/Occupational Therapist Resources for Treating ME/CFS” Facebook Group)
Fibromyalgia and other sources of pain
Temporomandibular Joint Disorder (TMJ)
Irritable bowel syndrome or Celiac Disease
Interstitial cystitis
Chronic pelvic pain
Multiple chemical sensitivity disorder
Secondary depression
Ehler’s Danlos Syndrome (including hEDS) or Hypermobile Spectrum Disorder (use the Beighton Scoring System- The Beighton score is a good screening tool that family doctors can use to detect generalized joint hypermobility. However, people often have hypermobility in joints not measured by the Beighton score, such as the jaw, neck, shoulders, wrists, hips, ankles, feet, and toes. In these situations, only relying on the Beighton score is not enough. If a person has joint hypermobility in many different areas throughout the body this can also be classified as generalized joint hypermobility. (www.Ehlers-Danlos.com)
Primary Sleep Disorders
Hypothalamic pituitary adrenal axis dysregulation
Doctors and patients should focus on symptoms that pose the most significant challenge, while learning ways to manage those symptoms to allow them to resume some activities and some quality of life.
Although there is no treatment for ME/CFS, here are some other therapies that may help with symptom management or coping with the changes in one’s life. However, please be cautious about therapies that claim to cure ME/CFS, as there are currently no cures for this illness, only management methods such as energy conservation, pacing activities in your day, prioritization, and aggressive rest. By using these management methods, it can help decrease the frequency, intensity, and length of post-exertional malaise episodes. This is important to prevent the individual with ME/CFS from developing permanent worsening and a lower baseline of functioning.
Different types of therapy that may be of benefit include:
Acceptance & Commitment Therapy (ACT)
Acupuncture
Chiropractic Treatments
Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT)
Counselling
Craniosacral therapy
Naturopathy
Meditation
Massage Treatments
Osteopathy (Perrin Technique for Manual Lymphatic & Glymphatic Drainage)
Psychotherapy
Trigger Point Therapy, Myofascial Release
Restorative Yoga in lying down (speak to a qualified ME-knowledgable healthcare professional before proceeding)
Important: CBT, ACT, and psychotherapy do NOT cure ME/CFS, and are only meant to be used to help patients with learning to cope with the emotions and changes in one’s life that accompany a chronic, physiological (and often invisible to the outside world) condition such as ME/CFS. Increased PEM, due to the cognitive and emotional effort involved of participating in CBT, ACT, or psychotherapy, is a real possibility that needs to be monitored closely. Graded Exercise Therapy (G.E.T.) is also NOT recommended for people with ME/CFS, as it can result in permanent worsening or lowering of a patient’s baseline of functioning.
We want to repeat: Unfortunately, there is currently no treatment or cure for ME/CFS, but patients can work at managing different symptoms they have with other treatments. As an example, let’s look at just pacing their daily activities or pain management.
Doctors can prescribe medications that ease pain and brain fog, and that improve sleep. The single most important thing a patient can do is to rest and pace themselves to avoid the level of exertion which worsens their symptoms. This is best done early on in the disease, and that is why early diagnosis is very important. Resting early on is associated with the best prognosis for ME/CFS patients. A pedometer or heart rate monitor (See here for more info on heart rate monitoring) can be very useful in this regard. These monitors can be set to alarm when a certain threshold is reached, alerting the patient to the need to stop and rest so as to avoid the onslaught of post-exertional malaise (PEM). Very severely affected patients may need to set a monitoring device to "sleep mode", even when they are awake, in order for it to pick up their very limited movements throughout the day.
Each patient's PEM (or anaerobic) threshold is unique to them, and depends on factors such as age, pre-illness physical fitness, and the severity of their illness. The best way to determine yours is to pay close attention to how you feel while doing different activities and pick the heart rate which corresponds to activities which do not trigger PEM versus those that do. Further information can also be found at the Workwell Foundation website.
The idea of pacing daily activities may sound simple enough to begin on one’s own, and although these principles sound overly easy, they do take some time to learn, implement, monitor, and adjust activity levels as necessary. A lot of it requires a change in mindset and remembering that it’s not a race to the finish line, but instead slow and steady that can help. Here are 5 very basic principles.
Stop before you overdo it.
Don’t use goals, but instead use internal cues.
Switch the type of activity
Insert rest periods in between activities.
Help yourself by using a diary or activity tracker.
Many things that can help are, in fact, not therapies but life skills that need to be adjusted because of ME/CFS. Pacing is just a pain and energy management strategy. It does not alleviate all symptoms of ME/CFS, but it can help reduce the number of times a patient’s PEM gets triggered.
A referral to a ME-knowledgable Occupational Therapist and/or Physiotherapist may be helpful for patients to learn how to implement the methods (of pacing activities of daily living, energy conservation, heart rate monitoring, pain modalities, etc) to manage their illness, but OT and PT cannot “fix” this illness. Instead, OT’s and PT’s (and physicians) can teach people how to MANAGE the illness. Physicians, Occupational Therapists or Physiotherapists can also complete the 10-minute NASA Lean Test, and learn more about how to assess for and treat the co-morbid conditions of ME/CFS, and communicate this to the physicians. Physicians, PT’s and OT’s also play an important role in recognizing co-morbid conditions in their patients, such as joint hypermobility or Ehlers Danlos Syndrome (EDS) which further hinder the energy, functioning, and quality of life of patients with ME/CFS.
You must also consider that asking a patient to attend appointments out of their home can also cause further decline in functioning as the time necessary to get ready, drive or be driven to appointments, attend appointments, etc. is very energy taxing (See Spoon Theory above) for the majority of people with ME/CFS.
We cannot stress the ME-knowledgable OT or PT enough. Harm (i.e. further decline in baseline functioning) has frequently happened in the past when patients were made to do traditional “Rehab, particularly physiotherapy” programs involving graded exercise (G.E.T.) to “restore their functioning.” See Physios for ME website.
Instead, the following commonly used PT/OT modalities can easily be adapted for utilization by the ME/CFS patient population: gentle soft tissue and joint mobilizations; thermal and electrical modalities; ADL/IADL efficiency trainings; safety training, especially focused on fall and decubitus ulcer prevention; ANS-retraining; assessment for and instructions in use of assistive devices; bracing and orthotics; gentle pain-management modalities; activities and environmental analysis and modifications; appropriate therapeutic exercise instruction (that focuses on ADL and IADL, if possible, without inducing PEM); and thoughtful referral to other helpful healthcare providers and/or collaboration with healthcare team. (Courtesy of the PT/OT Resources for Treating ME/CFS Facebook Group). Keep in mind that all therapeutic techniques, including ADL and IADL activities, must be monitored for the potential for PEM.
Doctors, please ensure that you are not causing more harm to your patients by referring them for inappropriate graded Rehab exercise programs (G.E.T.) that cause more functional decline, and can potentially cause a patient to become sicker and more housebound or bedbound. People have even deteriorated to the point of eventual death related to the illness (organ failure, as an example). The links provided throughout this website provide guidance for current best practice by ALL healthcare providers in order to ensure safe and competent practice be provided for people living with Myalgic Encephalomyelitis/Chronic Fatigue Syndrome.